South African Birthday Braai in Brooklyn with 36 Wines

Colorful coastal beach cottages. I have no pictures of wine country for this article because my husband accidentally deleted all of them. Yes, we are still married.

Today is my birthday and I turn 19, again. I am celebrating by throwing a Braai-style BBQ in Brooklyn to accompany a large, multi-regional tasting of wines procured from South Africa.  If I can’t spend my B-Day in Stellenbosch, then I will bring the spirit of the Cape Winelands to a Brooklyn Heights apartment with a bonafide patio and grill (unfortunately not mine, but a generous friend’s).

I spent weeks obtaining 36 wines from 18 vineyards. Most are samples, but a precious few are direct from my wine fridge, carefully cared for since bringing them back from South Africa 2 years, 3 months and 17 days ago.  And holy shit, I didn’t even look at the calendar before spitting out that number, and I just verified it was on the dot. Eerie!

Why a birthday party around South Africa? Skeptics say I can’t fall in love with a place I only knew seven days. Maybe I wasn’t there long enough to outgrow the honeymoon and commence day-to-day life with my sweetheart, flaws slowly unfurling, first charming, and eventually grating. Was I romanced by the vineyards of Stellenbosch, the adorable village of Franschhoek and long wine producing history of Constantia like a contestant on the Bachelor–all helicopters rides, fantasy suites and chiseled abs? Actually, that wasn’t my experience at all.

Most of the world is aware of South Africa’s history and problems, her citizens quite painfully. But with dramatic lows come equally dramatic highs, particularly with regard to her physical beauty; the scenery is flat-out stunning, probably made more so because I wasn’t expecting it. How often do close friends, even acquaintances, rave about her wines or the beauty of South African wine country? Most haven’t been, probably from fear of the 17-hour flight or misperceived cost of travel so far from home. Those who do visit, often consider South Africa synonymous with Kruger National Park or Table Mountain and Cape Town; and for the adventurous, maybe a cage-dip in Shark Alley to see the Great Whites.

But the flight is manageable (particularly with Valium, Ambien and free cocktails). South African Airways flies direct to Jo’burg from JFK, a United partner and accepting of FF miles. And without miles, airfare this summer (winter there) is on sale for $1000. That is cheaper than flying to Europe. Once arriving in Jo’Burg, you have an easy connection to Cape Town. Rent a car and off you go another 1.5 hours up to Stellenbosch. Yes, I know it sounds painful, but your reward is great. That first view of vineyards tucked into the mountains, laid-out one after another between the Wineland towns is heart-stopping.

Steenberg Winery patio. I only have this single photo to show.

The wineries are as sophisticated as Napa without pretension, and the lodging extraordinary in quality and variety offering relative reasonableness of price.  We spent several lovely nights in the Hawksmoor House, a beautiful B&B set in an old Cape Dutch country home filled thoughtfully with antiques and modern touches—a retreat to which you could imagine retiring one day. Each morning’s homemade breakfast was served on the patio with views over the rectangular garden pool that stretched to the mist-shrouded mountains beyond. Evenings at Hawksmoor offered complimentary dessert wines from the honor bar; we would slip into the house after dinner each night, choose our wine, and relax in whichever stately parlor room we fancied to pretend was ours for a few hours.

The restaurants are numerous, varied in cuisine and price; if your wine country vacation isn’t complete without fine multi-course dining, however, there are tasting menus to rival Yountville at half the price. We adored our anniversary dinner at Rust En Vrede, a 350-year old Country Dutch property that offers exceptional estate wines paired with their exemplary cuisine. Try a cocktail (or wine) on the balcony of the beautiful Delaire Graff Estate, watching the sun dip down, forever gone for that day, then pop over to Tokara restaurant across the road for dinner in a chic setting that belies the prices on the menu.

The wineries, however, impressed the most. I was struck over and over by the level of sophistication, attention to detail, aesthetics and use of technology. Part of what makes wine travel so fun is to see how each vintner and winery owner applies their personal-touch to the final wine and design of the buildings. Much of the architecture shows-off the charming Cape Dutch-look, but several were über-modern; all capitalized on the dramatic views, gardens and countryside greenery available to them. Overall, the wines were of reasonable price for very good quality (although only occasionally transcendental). South Africa is often associated with Chenin Blanc and Pinotage, but their Rhone and Bordeaux blends stand-out, and varietal bottlings of Syrah, Pinot Noir and Chardonnay deserve attention.

As is the case with most non-traditional European wine-producing regions, finding the same diversity of wines you sampled while visiting, back home in the States, is impossible. So the point of my tasting tonight is to explore the depths of what is available from South Africa in our market so as to inform friends and readers of this extraordinary place.  Greater demand for South African wines will bring more variety of selection. I plan to compile the tasting notes from this evening in my Unscrewed column in the Village Voice sometime in May or early June. Hopefully my words will encourage readers to spend more time considering South Africa on their store shelves and in their imaginations.

And for our Braai tonight? Yes, I know that we aren’t using real wood and a massive fire, so we are technically not doing it right. We are making do with what’s available in an urban environment, however, and working off cookbooks, the internet, an iPhone text and facebook messages, to put together a semi-authentic collection of dishes to pair with the wines. Below is our menu, and further down, our vinous line-up!


Peri Peri Shrimp and Chicken Drumsticks
Lamb Sosatie (kebabs)
Homemade Boerewors Sausage
Gestoofde Boontjies (fancy name for beans)
Hot Rice Salad
Chakalaka and Pap

Ash and Shawn Shooting Sausage for Boerewors

Pretty Boerewors Pinwheel!

Marinating Lamb Soastie


1 Bartinney Cabernet Sauvignon 2010
2 Bayten Sauvignon Blanc 2012
3 Beyerskloof Chenin Blanc/Pinotage 2012
4 Beyerskloof Synergy Blend 2010
5 Beyerskloof Pinotage 2012
6 Beyerskloof Diesel Pinotage 2009
7 Bradgate Sauv Blanc/Chenin Blanc 2011
8 Bradgate Cab Sauv/Merlot/Shiraz 2009
9 Bradgate Syrah 2010
10 Bruwer Raats Chenin Blanc 2011
11 Bruwer Raats Bordeaux Blend 2010
12 Cape Grace Chenin Blanc 2011
13 Cape Grace Pinotage 2011
14 Cape Grace Shiraz 2012
15 De Morgenzon Chardonnay 2012
16 De Morgenzon Chenin Blanc 2011
17 De Morgenzon Rose of Cabernet Sauvignon 2012
18 De Toren Fusion V 2008
19 Elgin Vintners Pinot Noir 2010
20 Elgin Vintners Chardonnay 2010
21 Excelsior Chardonnay/Viognier 2012
22 Excelsior Cabernet Sauvignon/Petit Verdot 2011
23 Glenelly Red Blend: Syrah, Cab, PV, M 2008
24 Hamilton Russell Chardonnay 2012
25 Hamilton Russell Pinot Noir 2010
26 Indaba Chenin Blanc 2012
27 Juno Cabernet Sauvignon 2010
28 Juno Shiraz 2010
29 Kanonkop Pinotage 2010
30 Kanonkop Pinotage Blend: Kadette 2009
31 Ken Forrester Chenin Blanc 2011
32 Ken Forrester Chenin Blanc 2012
33 Music by D’Aria Shiraz, Cab, Merlot 2009
34 Rudi Schultz Syrah 2010
35 Thelema The Mint Cabernet Sauvignon 2008
36 Thelema Mountain Red 2010


Filed under Birthday Braai and Tasting in Brooklyn, South Africa

7 responses to “South African Birthday Braai in Brooklyn with 36 Wines

  1. Love reading this! I’m a South African living in Istanbul, Turkey. A bit homesick and your menu made me lick my lips! You made me smile! Thank you!

  2. Thats a pretty well informed selection from SA wines, would have dropped the Juno wines. I understand you may not be shooting for the best wines, but the newly discovered wines of the Swartland deserve some recognition. Look for Mullineaux, Adi Badenhorst, and even Eben Sadie wines (if your budget allows)

  3. Suzaan

    It’s Bobotie. Not bobotjie

    And that is more like a Lamb Stew than sosaties. Sosatie means kebab or meat/veggies on a skewer.

    Juno does not belong on your list. Pretty good list otherwise. Thanks for the wonderful effort. It is really great.

    • LAM

      Hi Suzaan,
      Thank you for your note. In response to your comments, I have seen bobotie v. bobotjie spelled both ways (, and presumed the latter to be the more traditional since “tj” is a common traditional coupling of letters. Our Bobotjie or (tie) however you like, was more like a meatloaf than a stew: A friend who lived in South Africa a few years brought it. It was delicious, although I have no idea how classic it was since I have never had it before. The sosaties were skewers made from lamb, apricot, onions and other veggies. As for Juno, I had never heard of it and it was sent over, so we threw it in the pot. Another individual commented on that as well. Maybe to your market it is like Turning Leaf to us? Anyway, it didn’t do very well;) There are so many good wines from S.A. we could really do this ten more times and still scratch the surface!
      Thanks for reading.

  4. I agree with Kevin about the wonderful wines of the Swartland, an up and coming wine area! Juno does have an amazing label! Lived in Paarl where they had a Bistro too. very colourful! And Suzaan, too much criticism!!! Living away from SA you don’t always have a big choice of SA wine. I’m just so happy that a young New Yorker can party the South African way…well done! Wish I was there 🙂

    • LAM

      Thanks Maddie! We had a great time and I am working to upload some pictures this week. I loved that everyone got involved and really tried to make an authentic dish. One issue with gathering a lot of S.A. wines in one place is that there is really only one East Coast importer who has a large collection of them: Cape Classics. The rest of what is brought in is scattered between importers throughout the country, many who focus on other countries as well, thus they may only have a bottle or three of S.A wine in their line-up. And even then, they are not all available in our East coast market due regional licensing rules (although NYC is the largest for sure). It is like hunting and picking to amass a lot of S.A. wine at once!

      I haven’t tried any wines from Swartland. I will have to look into who might import some. Or even better, visit in person!
      Thanks for all the comments.

  5. Pingback: Nelson Mandela and His Vinous Legacy in South Africa | CHASING THE VINE

Leave a Reply to LAM Cancel reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.